Friendly, Committed And Always Working For You

Our attorneys have the skills, experience and dedication needed to help families, individuals & businesses make smart, informed legal decisions in Alabama.

My home insurance company won’t return my calls. Now what?

On Behalf of | Aug 23, 2025 | Homeowner's Insurance Matters |

When you are dealing with damage to your home and your insurance company will not return your calls, the frustration you may understandably feel can be overwhelming. In Alabama, insurance companies are required to handle claims in good faith, which includes communicating with policyholders on time. Silence or constant delays may signal that the company that insures your home is trying to avoid paying your claim or is hoping you will give up. 

Thankfully, homeowners do not have to accept this treatment, and there are steps you can take to protect your rights.

The most important first steps you should take

The first thing you’ll want to do is review your policy carefully. Knowing exactly what is covered, what deadlines apply and what exclusions may exist puts you in a strong position to make informed choices about your circumstances. Sometimes insurers fail to return calls because they hope you will misunderstand your coverage and abandon your claim. By understanding your policy, you’ll reduce the chances of being misled and will be better prepared to demand what you are entitled to.

If multiple phone calls are not being returned, consider sending a formal letter. Written communication, especially when sent by certified mail, can compel the insurance company to acknowledge your claim in writing. Under Alabama law, insurers are expected to respond to claims within a reasonable timeframe. A letter can create a paper trail that can prove that they failed to do so.

If your insurance company remains unresponsive 

If these initial efforts do not lead to a favorable resolution of your situation, it may be time to involve a skilled legal team. Insurance companies sometimes engage in what is known as bad faith conduct—unreasonably delaying, denying or otherwise failing to communicate about a valid claim. When this happens, homeowners have the right to pursue legal remedies. 

Homeowners pay premiums expecting that when disaster strikes, their insurance company will be there to help. If you are met with silence instead, know that you are not powerless. By documenting your efforts, understanding your policy, putting your requests in writing and seeking legal support when necessary, you can push back against unresponsive insurers and protect your home and financial well-being. In Alabama, the law is on your side if your insurance company refuses to uphold its obligations.

FindLaw Network